What Should Leaseholders Look for in Service Charge Accounts?
Qube Talk: Service Charge Accounting Insights
Welcome to another episode of Qube Talk, where we discuss all things service charge accounting.
I’m Ray Armand, and I’m joined by CJ Ralfe.
Today, we’re putting ourselves in the shoes of a leaseholder.
Imagine you arrive at an AGM and you’re handed a set of service charge accounts.
What should you actually look at?
What figures matter?
What questions should you ask?
And how can you tell whether something deserves further explanation?
This episode is useful for leaseholders, but it is equally useful for managing agents.
If you understand which parts of the accounts leaseholders are likely to focus on, you can prepare better explanations, improve transparency and reduce unnecessary confusion.
Step 1: Start With the Independent Accountant’s Report
CJ Ralfe:
The first thing I would look at is the independent accountant’s report, sometimes referred to as a report of factual findings, or the audit report where an audit has been carried out.
Look carefully at whether the accountant has included any qualifications, disclaimers or points that need attention.
That is a useful starting point because the accountant’s report may highlight areas where:
Something could not be independently verified
A balance could not be supported in the usual way
A material issue was identified
An important matter needs to be brought to the leaseholders’ attention
What Does a Disclaimer Mean?
A disclaimer or qualification does not automatically mean the accounts are wrong.
It may simply mean that the accountant could not obtain the type of evidence they would ideally have wanted.
For example, imagine the managing agent holds all client money for several developments in one pooled bank account.
The accountant may be able to agree the development’s balance to the managing agent’s internal cash book or accounting system.
However, they may not be able to agree that individual development balance directly to a standalone external bank statement.
That could result in the accountant drawing attention to the limitation.
The key point is:
Read the accountant’s report before jumping straight to the numbers.
It may give you important context about the rest of the accounts.
Step 2: Look for a Balance Sheet
The next thing to look for is a balance sheet.
A good set of service charge accounts should help you understand not only the income and expenditure for the year, but also the financial position at the year end.
The balance sheet can show items such as:
Bank balances
Service charge debtors
Creditors
Reserve or sinking funds
Other year-end balances
If you only receive a statement of income and expenditure, you may not be seeing the full financial picture.
Step 3: Look at the Bank Balance
One of the most important figures is the bank balance.
CJ:
Cash is king.
If there is a separate bank account for the development, that gives you a clear external reference point.
A standalone bank statement can provide assurance about how much money is physically being held for that site.
Is There a Separate Bank Account for the Development?
As a leaseholder, I would generally prefer the development to have a separate designated client account.
That makes the financial position easier to understand.
It can also make things clearer if:
The development changes managing agent
A financial dispute arises
Leaseholders want evidence of funds held
The accounts need to be reconciled
There are questions about cash flow
Where several developments are pooled into one client bank account, the managing agent may maintain separate internal cash book balances for each site.
That can work operationally, but it can make independent verification and handovers more complicated.
Why Separate Bank Accounts Can Help During Handovers
If your development moves from one managing agent to another, a separate bank account can make it easier to establish exactly how much cash belongs to the site.
Where the money is part of a much larger pooled account, the outgoing and incoming managing agents may need to rely more heavily on internal accounting records to establish the amount due.
That can become a point of disagreement.
Step 4: Look at Service Charge Debtors
After looking at the bank balance, another important figure is service charge debtors.
Debtors represent amounts that are still owed to the development.
In practical terms, this could mean leaseholders who have not yet paid all of the service charges due.
Why Debtors Matter to Every Leaseholder
Imagine you always pay your service charge on time.
You attend the AGM and the managing agent explains that the development is experiencing cash-flow difficulties.
Then you look at the balance sheet and see:
£50,000 of service charges still outstanding.
That is important information.
It may explain why the development is short of cash.
The problem may not be that the budget was inadequate.
It may simply be that a significant amount of the service charge due has not yet been collected.
Ask About Large Outstanding Service Charges
Useful questions might include:
How much service charge remains unpaid?
How old are those balances?
What action is being taken to collect them?
Are a small number of leaseholders responsible for most of the outstanding amount?
As a group of leaseholders or RMC directors, significant outstanding service charge debt should be something you understand.
Step 5: Compare Actual Expenditure With the Budget
Once you have looked at the balance sheet, move to the statement of income and expenditure.
One of the most useful comparisons is:
Actual expenditure versus budget.
The budget tells you what the managing agent expected to spend.
The service charge accounts show what was actually spent.
Comparing the two can highlight areas that deserve explanation.
Check That Service Charge Income Makes Sense
Look at the service charge income for the year.
Does it broadly agree with what was expected to be raised under the budget?
If not, ask why.
There may be a perfectly reasonable explanation, but the managing agent should understand the difference.
Ask for the Budget to Be Included in the Accounts
Ideally, the service charge accounts themselves should include a budget comparison.
That makes the information much easier to understand.
For example:
Category | Budget | Actual |
Cleaning | £X | £X |
Gardening | £X | £X |
Repairs | £X | £X |
Insurance | £X | £X |
This allows leaseholders to immediately see where there have been significant over- or underspends.
If your service charge accounts do not include the budget, it is perfectly reasonable to ask whether future accounts could include a budget comparison.
Why Including the Budget in the Accounts Helps
The budget may group expenditure differently from the final service charge accounts.
For example, the budget may use one category name while the accounts use another.
If the accountant or preparer includes the budget comparison directly in the service charge accounts, they can make sure the figures have been aligned on a like-for-like basis.
That makes comparisons much easier.
Step 6: Look for Large Budget Variances
Run your eye down the expenditure.
Look for categories that are significantly above or below budget.
Repairs and maintenance is often one of the areas where large differences can occur.
That does not automatically mean something has gone wrong.
Perhaps there was:
An emergency repair
Unexpected building damage
A lift breakdown
Roof work
Major plumbing repairs
Additional contractor work
But significant differences deserve an explanation.
Under Budget Is Not Always the Whole Story Either
An underspend can sound positive.
But it may also mean planned work was postponed.
For example, if £10,000 was budgeted for maintenance and only £2,000 was spent, ask:
Was the work no longer required?
Was it postponed?
Will it need to be carried out next year?
The figure alone does not tell the whole story.
Step 7: Look at Significant or Major Expenditure
Large individual costs should attract your attention.
One area to be aware of is Section 20 consultation requirements.
Where qualifying works or certain long-term agreements cross the relevant statutory thresholds, there can be formal consultation requirements.
If you see a large piece of expenditure, it is reasonable to ask:
Was a Section 20 process required?
If so, was it completed?
Were leaseholders notified?
Were quotes or tenders obtained?
What Is Section 20 in Simple Terms?
Section 20 is essentially about giving leaseholders protection when significant amounts of their money are being spent.
The process can require consultation and transparency before certain major works or qualifying long-term agreements proceed.
From a leaseholder’s perspective, the principle is straightforward:
If a managing agent is spending a significant amount on your behalf, you want confidence that:
The expenditure was necessary
The correct process was followed
Leaseholders were informed
Appropriate quotes or tenders were considered
There was a clear procurement process
Major Works Should Not Come as a Complete Surprise
If major work appears in the service charge accounts and you had no idea it happened, that is an obvious question to raise.
Managing agents should ideally be communicating significant projects throughout the year.
The year-end accounts should not be the first time leaseholders discover that a major amount was spent.
Long-Term Contracts Can Also Matter
Section 20 considerations can also arise around certain longer-term contracts.
For example, a cleaning or landscaping contract may look like an ordinary operating expense.
But if it is entered into for a longer period and meets the relevant criteria, additional consultation requirements may apply.
The important point for a leaseholder is simply to recognise large or long-term commitments and ask whether the correct procedures were followed.
Step 8: Review Reserve and Sinking Funds
Another major area to examine is the reserve fund or sinking fund.
Reserve funds are amounts built up over time for future expenditure.
They may be used for things such as:
Roof replacement
Lift works
Road repairs
Major external works
Heating systems
Other long-term maintenance
As a leaseholder, you should understand:
Whether a reserve fund exists
What it is intended for
How much is being contributed
What has been spent
How much remains
Whether the balance is appropriate for the expected future works
Reserve Funds Become More Complex on Multi-Schedule Developments
Reserve funds require even more attention where the development contains several service charge areas.
For example, a site may include:
Flats
Terraced houses
Standalone houses
Garages
Parking areas
Commercial units
Shared estate areas
Different groups may be responsible for different costs.
A Multi-Schedule Example
Imagine the flats have a lift.
The houses do not.
The flats may therefore contribute to a reserve for future lift works.
At the same time, the whole estate may contribute towards future road repairs.
So you might have:
£3,000 contributed towards the lift reserve
and
£5,000 contributed towards the estate road reserve.
Those two amounts should not simply lose their identity once they enter the overall reserve fund.
Make Sure Different Reserve Funds Stay Separate
If the £3,000 and £5,000 are simply combined into one £8,000 reserve balance, problems can arise later.
Imagine the road repairs cost more than expected.
The overall reserve may look healthy because it contains money contributed by the flats for the lift.
The development could accidentally use money intended for the lift to pay for the roads.
Then, when the lift eventually needs major work, there may be a shortfall.
The flat owners could end up being asked to contribute again even though they had already built up funds for that purpose.
That is clearly unfair.
Why Historic Reserve Problems Can Become Very Difficult
This may sound obvious when explained simply.
In practice, it can become extremely complicated.
Reserve funds can build up over:
Five years
Ten years
Fifteen years
During that time, money may be:
Added
Spent
Transferred
Used to cover deficits
Reallocated
If the different schedules have not been properly tracked, it can become extremely difficult to work out whose money is whose.
What Leaseholders Should Look for on Multi-Schedule Accounts
If you live on a multi-schedule development, ask whether the accounts clearly show the financial position of your particular service charge area.
You should ideally be able to understand:
How much income was raised for your area
What expenditure related to your area
Whether your area had a surplus or deficit
How much reserve money belongs to your area
What reserve expenditure occurred
Income Should Be Transparent Too
Sometimes service charge accounts show one total income figure for the entire development but then split the expenditure between different schedules.
That can make it difficult for somebody in one particular schedule to understand their financial position.
If you are in Schedule 3, you should ideally be able to understand how Schedule 3 performed.
Transparency matters.
Check That Percentage Splits Appear Reasonable
Not every cost can always be directly allocated.
Some expenditure may need to be split between several parts of a development.
Where percentages are used, ask yourself whether they appear reasonable and whether they agree with the lease or other governing documentation.
The split should not simply be an arbitrary percentage that nobody can explain.
A Simple Leaseholder Checklist for Service Charge Accounts
If you are handed service charge accounts at an AGM, work through the following areas.
1. Read the Independent Accountant’s Report
Look for:
Qualifications
Disclaimers
Matters raised
Areas that could not be independently verified
2. Check There Is a Balance Sheet
Look for:
Cash
Debtors
Creditors
Reserves
3. Review the Bank Balance
Ask:
How much cash is held?
Is there a separate designated bank account?
Can the balance be independently verified?
4. Look at Service Charge Debtors
Ask:
How much remains unpaid?
Is this creating cash-flow problems?
What is being done to recover outstanding balances?
5. Compare Budget With Actual Expenditure
Look for:
Large overspends
Significant underspends
Unexpected expenditure
6. Investigate Major Costs
Ask:
What was the expenditure for?
Was it communicated?
Were relevant consultation or procurement procedures followed?
7. Review Reserve Funds
Understand:
What money has been accumulated
What it is intended for
What has been spent
Whether different schedules are separately tracked
8. Understand Your Own Schedule
If the development has multiple service charge areas, make sure you can identify the financial position of the area you contribute to.
Don't Be Overwhelmed by Service Charge Accounts
CJ:
People often say:
“I don't understand accounts.”
And then they only look at the bottom line or the bank balance.
But once you know the basic areas to focus on, it becomes much easier.
You don't need to become an accountant.
You simply need to know which questions to ask.
What Managing Agents Can Learn From This
This episode is also extremely useful for managing agents.
Put yourself in the leaseholder’s shoes.
Before issuing the service charge accounts, ask:
If I were a leaseholder, what would I question?
Would they understand:
The bank balance?
Outstanding debt?
Budget variances?
Major works?
Reserve fund movements?
Their individual schedule?
If you already know which questions are coming, you can answer them proactively.
Better Communication Creates Happier Clients
Managing agents may already be doing many things correctly.
The problem may simply be that clients do not know about them.
If you:
Follow proper procurement processes
Maintain separate client accounts
Track reserves accurately
Carry out consultation
Review budgets
Chase outstanding service charges
make sure the relevant information is being communicated.
Clients cannot value something they do not know you are doing.
The Key Takeaway
When reviewing service charge accounts, don't only look at the final surplus or deficit.
Look at the story behind the numbers.
Start with the accountant’s report.
Review the balance sheet.
Understand the cash.
Look at what is owed.
Compare the budget with actual expenditure.
Question significant costs.
Understand the reserves.
And if your development has multiple schedules, make sure the financial information is clear enough to show where your money has gone.
LISTEN HERE
Want to hear Ray and CJ discuss what leaseholders should look for when reviewing service charge accounts in more detail?
Follow Qube Talk for more discussions covering:
Service charge accounting
Leaseholder rights and questions
Managing agents
Service charge budgets
Reserve and sinking funds
Section 20
RMC and RTM accounting
Multi-schedule developments
Residential block management
Year-end service charge accounts
Why Not Get in Touch With the Team at Qube Accountants?
Are you a managing agent looking to make your service charge accounts clearer, more transparent and easier for leaseholders to understand?
Or perhaps you need specialist support with:
Service charge account preparation
Independent reviews
Multi-schedule accounts
Reserve and sinking funds
Budget comparisons
Year-end financial reporting
Historic service charge accounting issues
Why not get in touch with the team at Qube Accountants?
We specialise in service charge accounting for managing agents and understand the unique accounting challenges involved in residential block management.
Our team works with managing agents to produce clear financial information that helps clients understand:
What money was collected
Where it was spent
What remains outstanding
What is held in reserves
How different service charge schedules performed
This article is based on a Qube Talk podcast discussion and is intended to provide general information rather than legal advice. Individual leases, service charge arrangements and developments vary, so appropriate professional or legal advice should be obtained where required.
Comments